E-Commerce

Etsy’s push for higher quality search results is pushing prices up too

The company says its buyers are responding well to rising listing prices, and its own search improvements are increasingly surfacing pricier items over cheaper alternatives.

Etsy told investors on its second-quarter 2026 earnings call, held Wednesday 16th September, that average order value grew 2.8% year-on-year to $124 in the quarter.

Gross merchandise sales reached $2.6 billion for the quarter, up 7.5% year-on-year.

Chief financial officer Lanny Baker said a wave of seller price increases over the past year, driven by tariffs and the expiry of the de minimis exemption, has been absorbed well by buyers. “We have seen our buyers be very receptive to those price changes,” he said.

Baker described a second, separate factor behind the AOV growth: changes to how Etsy surfaces items in search. He called it “the new signal that started to emerge across 2026”, saying Etsy’s relevance and quality improvements are increasingly presenting buyers with higher quality, higher priced items that better match what they are searching for.

He said this effect is contributing to AOV “on an increasing basis”, alongside the pass-through from sellers’ own price rises, which he expects to remain durable.

STAY AHEAD OF UK ECOMMERCE

Found this useful? This is one of dozens of updates like it we track every week. Get the ones that matter to UK sellers in your inbox, twice a week – free.

Etsy is also building richer profiles of individual shoppers, now covering 65 million buyers, that feed into search personalisation, recommendations and marketing. Chief executive Kruti Patel Goyal said these profiles get “richer and richer the more that you engage”, and are increasingly used to match buyers to specific “shopping missions” rather than broad categories.

Trailing twelve-month GMS per active buyer also grew, and Etsy’s active buyer count rose for the first time in three years, reaching approximately 87 million.

The update comes as Etsy cuts roughly 220 jobs, about 12% of its workforce, concentrated in product and engineering. The company says the restructuring is meant to sharpen its focus on machine learning and search personalisation, not to cut costs.

Filed underEtsy

Mike Callachan is the founder of Beyond the Basket, a twice-weekly newsletter covering UK ecommerce. He has run online shops for more than a decade, most recently a personalised gift business selling across WooCommerce, Etsy and TikTok Shop. He writes about the platform changes, regulation and marketing shifts that land on small sellers first.